Reviews

Courthouse on Horseback (2006)
P
PaivaNovember 22, 2023
PaivaNovember 22, 2023Contains spoilers
In my opinion, it could have been a great movie if not for a few major flaws. The narrative is too fragmented, the plot has bad pacing, and the characters don't get enough screen time to be fully developed. The subject matter is actually excellent - the lives of "rural judges" on horseback and the conflicting views between the rookie judge and the veteran about the profession and love. The villagers from the "Yi" ethnic group look slightly uneasy on camera, but it's understandable because they are not trained actors. The female judge, however, did an excellent performance with her subtle and natural way of acting. Some of the emotions conveyed through her performance left me unable to speak with a heavy heart. The impact of the film could have been much stronger had the director's realist approach to the subject matter not ended up with an ending that is way too vague and inconclusive.

Courthouse on Horseback (2006)
N
Ninja_sNovember 22, 2023
Ninja_sNovember 22, 2023The villagers on camera appear selfish, unruly, and vile. Being real villagers who were paid to act in the movie, they represent a group of people who resorted to being extremely cunning and pragmatic as their coping mechanism amidst the abrupt transition from a backward rural lifestyle to rapid modernization. When the way to resolving villagers' cases involves enticement or even bribery, the story instantly fails to convey the director's original intended message. The significance of the judiciary is lost when law has to be carried out in such twisted and perverse manners.

Swallowtail Butterfly (1996)
M
Moonlight_meets_MNovember 22, 2023
Moonlight_meets_MNovember 22, 2023This may be Shunji Iwai's most ambitious and grand film to date. It portrays Japan as a "center of the world" with an anti-utopia setting focusing on the stories of lower-class immigrants. The relationships between people are both precious and cheap to them. However, perhaps because too much time was dedicated to creating a new atmosphere, the ending feels incomplete.

Swallowtail Butterfly (1996)
F
Filipa476November 22, 2023
Filipa476November 22, 2023Many people probably didn't understand this film when it was released, because its creative concept is far ahead of other contemporary Japanese films. The story seems to revolve around money, but it's actually about Japan's deepening problem of illegal immigration, intertwined with the dreams of marginalized characters. It's not just a group portrait, but every supporting character in the film is fully fleshed out, especially Feihong. He's manipulated by money, which is both ironic and alludes to the inescapable cycle of illegal immigrants being stuck at the bottom of society, yet it also leaves a glimmer of hope.

Ararat (2002)
E
e88mieu1November 22, 2023
e88mieu1November 22, 2023Contains spoilers
Atom Egoyan uses his familiar multi-linear narrative structure in this film, where the form of a play within a play creates the illusion of traveling through time and space, coupled with an extremely dramatic and cheesy familial relationship. The way characters and events are handled is somewhat similar to that in "Once Upon a Time in Anatolia”, which describes the entire nation's past and the present by portraying every individual's emotions. It seems like wishful thinking on the security officer's part when he discovers the drugs but still lets the boy go in the end. The story is rather loosely paced and relies too much on dialogue, and the aesthetic isn't that great either.

Ararat (2002)
R
Raúlo_l_lNovember 22, 2023
Raúlo_l_lNovember 22, 2023As a film about historical truth and memories, this is the most literary and artistically valuable film of its kind that I have ever seen. As a play within a play, it boasts the best narrative techniques among similar films I've seen. As a segmented group portrait, this is the most naturally crafted, emotionally sincere and correct film of its kind that I have ever seen.

Zama (2017)
J
JuanfishNovember 22, 2023
JuanfishNovember 22, 2023The story is set in the era of slavery in Latin America. The cinematography resembles period oil paintings, but the director isn't recreating history. Instead, she incorporated absurdity, tying the protagonist's fate with exotic places and spectacles as well as the historical backdrop. The whimsical music, makeup and costumes make the film even more dramatic. I was drawn in by the stills, but due to my limited knowledge, I couldn't see anything deeper than the tragedy of yearning to but being unable to return to civilization while living amidst the savages.

Zama (2017)
P
P3atríciaNovember 22, 2023
P3atríciaNovember 22, 2023Compared to other directors from the same period seeking aesthetical and stylistic innovation, directors like Lucrecia Martel have achieved more. Even if you recognized all the filmmaking techniques in her films, you'd still feel perplexed at first glance, for she has stripped away the narrative function almost entirely, leaving you - like her protagonists - lost in history and unable to see the path forward clearly, merely being forced to go with the flow of life.

City of God (2002)
S
saNTOS_7November 22, 2023
saNTOS_7November 22, 2023It’s stunning and shocking! Certain scenes are often used as examples for audiovisual analysis. The combination of extremely long shots and close-ups, unstable handheld cameras, fast cuts, plentiful use of strobe lighting, and dynamic camera movements, create a sense of urgency and speed. As a realistic story about a group of violent, bloody and evil children, the director employs audiovisual language to the extreme in this film, which is quite rare. God has forgotten his city, and the youth are demons incarnate.

City of God (2002)
T
tinaShayNovember 22, 2023
tinaShayNovember 22, 2023Not just guns, photography can also change destinies. It's blood and violence, the law of the jungle, and a Rio that you can't find on a postcard. The editing is as lively and exuberant as samba music.

Before the Rain (1994)
C
CherryBlossumYNovember 22, 2023
CherryBlossumYNovember 22, 2023Contains spoilers
I almost couldn't give it a full rating. The close-up shots from different angles are made into a fast cut and further enhanced with music to give it a feeling of mystic while boosting the film's aesthetics at the same time. The director's talent and techniques are most evident in the depiction of the never-ending ethnic conflicts in the Balkans through the story of the "tomboy" and the unsolved murder case. The outstanding story and visuals helped compensate for the lack of coherence in the story and the slightly contrived structuralism tendencies.

Before the Rain (1994)
R
Ro_con_4November 22, 2023
Ro_con_4November 22, 2023I absolutely cannot tolerate those who have no regard for life, killing at the slightest provocation simply because others have different beliefs, are from a different ethnic group, or think differently. I can't comprehend such unloving cultures or religions.

Before the Rain (1994)
G
gememilyNovember 22, 2023
gememilyNovember 22, 2023This is the first time I've seen a movie making its mark in the film industry for its nonsensical loops. My watching experience could be described as "confusion", but it did give me a lot of mixed emotions. Hatred is like the never-ending loops depicted in the film.

What Happens Later (2023)
1
11lieselotteNovember 22, 2023
11lieselotteNovember 22, 2023It all makes sense when you know it's "based on a play". Meg is still Meg, but the male lead is pretty forgettable. You're telling me two exes can spend the night chatting when they are stranded at an airport? No offense, but as a Gen Y, this sounds a little too far-fetched, but I guess it's just normal for boomers. Meg has so many classics and I'm a huge fan of hers, but clearly, this movie is nowhere near those classics. The whole film feels more like a nostalgia trip designed specifically for the male white boomers. Since it is Meg's directorial debut, it's fine I guess, but please don't do it again. I still prefer your sweet romcoms from last time.

What Happens Later (2023)
S
saNTOS_7November 22, 2023
saNTOS_7November 22, 2023Meg Ryan weaves her various past experiences into the dialogue in this film. Perhaps it's been a while since I've seen her on screen, but I find her demeanor a little bit psycho. Thankfully, David Duchovny's performance seamlessly complements her unpredictable mental state, including that awkward dance scene. The most remarkable part, however, is David Duchovny's portrayal replacing Dennis Quaid, as Russell Crowe accepts some of Meg Ryan's grievances and subsequently finds solace. As her debut film as a director, it does feel somewhat unpolished, especially in terms of emotional shifts and scene transitions. Nonetheless, I would still recommend it for the efforts.

Last Suspect (2023)
S
SeemoreNovember 22, 2023
SeemoreNovember 22, 2023It’s a typical case within a case situation, a setup within a setup. The twist really surprised me, and perhaps that's the beauty of this movie. Besides the well-written plot itself, the performance of the cast, including Kara Wai, has all played a crucial role in making this movie a success. I’m really impressed by Kara Wai’s explosive performance. Of course, the film also delves into the exploration of legal and moral boundaries at the end, questioning the meaning of justice.

Last Suspect (2023)
A
Alan-zum3November 22, 2023
Alan-zum3November 22, 2023Contains spoilers
Overall, it’s quite unconventional - the person you believed was not the killer turned out to be the actual killer, and the plot was convincing enough to support such an ending. Hong-Chi Lee's acting is really good, and Boogie Wang's performance exceeded my expectations. Kara Wai did really amazingly, too! The downfall of the film lies in its ending. First, the bunch of police officers always show up after everything is resolved, which is really frustrating. Also, the subplot about the little girl being kidnapped seems unnecessary. Overall, I think it could have been better if the director injected more of her own artistic expression into this film, and not relied so much on the same old formulas.

Last Suspect (2023)
F
Fiona-wow6November 22, 2023
Fiona-wow6November 22, 2023Contains spoilers
It’s another movie targeting the female audience and it's bad, especially when the director is a woman. The excessive "male gaze" in the film is so silly, and was it really necessary to prove maternal love through such cruelty? You do not need to re-enact the victim's persecution to show the pain and suffering. What's the difference between this and what attorney Chen calls "secondary victimization"? Those contrived plot twists are really amateur. Neither the main storyline nor the depiction of maternal love is well done, not to mention the courtroom scenes and the process of solving the case, which all seemed like they were put together haphazardly.

The Killer (2023)
T
theohoratioNovember 22, 2023
theohoratioNovember 22, 20233.5/10. The killer who utilizes modern internet and IoT systems to kill seems to take on a metaphorical sense when examining the isolated lives of modern people. The story takes an unexpected turn towards the end. Rather than calling it a movie, it feels more like a chaptered first-person video game, something like "Hitman: Agent 47”. Ok...I think I've rambled a bit too much, but I do consider this film one of Fincher's better works.

The Killer (2023)
L
Let's Talk About...November 22, 2023
Let's Talk About...November 22, 2023Many auteurs often set aside their "labels" and change their mindsets when reaching a certain age. David Fincher has ditched his usual style, opting to slow down and immerse himself in the aesthetics of the thriller genre. The story itself is quite simple, but the structure, the emotions, and the pacing are all meticulously handled. The cinematography and sound design are commendable as well, as the exciting audiovisual language kept me focused on the development of the story. The deliberate intertwining of the killer's thought processes and his dialogues with other characters clearly reflects the careful considerations of the auteur in adopting such a way of storytelling.