Your Worst Nightmare (2014)★ 7.2/10
- Crime
- Documentary
Directed by: Dan Bush, Scott Thigpen, Rob Schmidt, Douglas Berger, Georgia Tanner
Written by: Emily Altmann, Amy Briamonte, Joanna Brooks, Alissa Collins, Castor Fernandez
Narrated reenactments of key events with commentary from law enforcement officers, criminal justice professionals, and friends and family of victims.
Directed by
Written by
Cast & crew
D.C. GoodeNarratorJason ShablikNarrator
Clark SarulloShow Opening VictimEric AbrahamShow open intruder
Robin BloodworthDetective Pat RogersDamian LovelloDeputy Steve Beebe
John BranchDetective Tony
Shawn AliBryan LindonKevin Todde CoughlinCreepy Delivery ManBrody WellmakerInvestigator Kenny Rodgers
Kirsten Ray JohnsonTammy
J. Benedict LarmoreAlan WadeTimothy BattenBob NewburgVictoria FrazerKatie Ahearn
Levi BurdickBrian BrailsfordDrew LamkinsDet. Jeff MelliesZeph JewellJim Woodlee
David TurnerDale MullenbergEdward Michael ScottJim Conway
Nasir RahimFBI Agent #1
Angela Marie WilliamsCSI Sanchez
Cuyle CarvinCapt. Steve Rogers
Jon ArthurOfficer Hoffman
Jeff SprauveCrime Scene TechKristin BrockTennyson Jacobson
Justin TorrenceDeputy Trautman
Ali AshtigoGeorge TedescoStephen CaudillDet. Tom Pettis
Trevor DavidCrime Tech Ronald EvansMichelle CottonOfficer #1
Patrick Lamont Jr.Horace LandersVinny CostaArlington Officer #1Anthony TriceriAgent Tom Bush
Harlan Wenonah RoseBaby JohnnyQuincy VillanuevaHotel ManagerFrank JenningsJerry WooldridgeBecky Lindsay ShawJan the Waitress
Brent GlennDetective Bill Blanchard
Jes DistadAnne Marie
Derrell Keith LesterPolice Officer #2Bret David ThompsonOfficer Sean DonovanJoy RoperNancy Harris
Hannah AllineSarah Harris
Sarafina KingMartha Brailsford
Muretta MossMary Stauffer
Jimmy DempsterHank
Jason VailFrank Andrews
Brianne CordaroKaye RobinsonAlex ZukoGary TaylorCyrah HillAdriane Fields
Taylor KalupaKari Swenson
Catherine DyerDeborah Houchin
Sam BrooksSerf Barnabei
Julia VasiJodi Sanderholm
Devon HalesKaren Slattery
Cindy HoganGail Spencer
Jason MacDonaldTom Maimoni
Kenneth TrujilloJim Filiaggi
Samantha BinkerdJennifer Holliday
Karen BolesSandi Musk
Kate KovachLisa Filiaggi
Brianna FerrisSandy Jeffers
Ben MathenyOfficer Tim SchultzGina Ann RiggsDawn Heikilla
Dustin WhiteheadMark Eskridge
Samantha JancoBre LasleySara TorresAshleigh Lindsey
Rowan BousaidMaurice MasonEmily Paige HoganCatherine MahaffeyTyler WebsterBrian DraperHeather LydaJulie BoydKatherine OlsenJenae Aragosa
Jeff ColeDon Nichols
Courtney DietzLori Virden
Sarah BorneAna Franklin
Jeff RoseDetective Doug Hudson
Amye GoussetTara Woodlee
Randy SpenceKenneth Boyd
Kelly TippensAmy Tinch
Skylar Morgan JonesBecky Helms
Kalyn WoodCassie Jo Stoddart
Erin BoswellKayli Lasley
Darren CainTrevor Fredrick
Jonathan KleitmanMatthew HeikkilaJonah LimbertJoby PalczynzkiNathan ParkerJim StrongDorian Alexis SantiagoDet. ProsniewskiChristian CarmeanAndy LefleurAndrew BellamyAaron Skeen
Ben VanderMeyJosh Heikkila
Braxton BjerkenNick Robinson
Skyler JoySarah Wisnosky
Cory ChapmanTory Adamcik
Johnny LandTravis
Chris ShurleyLarry Musk
Kevin HarrisonCarlos Hess
Alan PhelpsCraig CurryMaggie WilderHeather Lara
Richie JohnsonRobert BergerChase PeacockAnthony MandatoClay GwaltneyAlex Burke
Vanessa FrenchCindy Sanderholm
Cathy JohnsRobin FranklinShelby HoferGloria ShenkAriel JonesAmy Helms
Franco CastanAlan Goldstein
Justin Matthew SmithGeorge Shenk
Kellen BoyleJosh Scott
Hannah AslesenSusan Ryan
Gwydion Lashlee-WaltonChristopher Boyd
Rebecca LinesAnita Byers
Shane CallahanDouglas Desilva
Tommy McNultyDavid Helms
Patrick FlemingOfficer Ben Hone
Burke BrownJustin Thurber
Daniel BaldockEric Parnell
Tanya FreemanJoanie Smith
Andrew SweeneyJohn Ganske
Carolyn Jones EllisVera Crum
Sylvia Castro GalanLinda's MotherMaria LegardaJacinda Welsch
Rich RobertsonCalder Pinkston
Al BianchiLester WinninghamChristina ReynoldsSgt Sharon MooreLola FernandezBecky Germain
Matt MercurioTrooper Brian Roberts
Bryan HibbardJosh Mahaffey
Ryan CzerwonkoDavid Meyers
Zuri JamesKeith Dozier
Bruno RoseAndre Hall
Angela RayLibrarian
Lindsay AbernathyRosemaryAli WhiteBlonde Woman
Benjamin DavidAgt. David Falletti
Beverley SimmonsVicky ReinkenJason SkeenInvestigator Kent Ferguson
Debra CrittendenBetty CurryMatt HendrenMatthew YoungAdele LatellOperator Stephanie Davidson
Kelley LockmanDetective Greg GloverMary Shannon RussellChanin Starbuck
T.J. GarlandDeputy Young
Chase AndersonBrett Kelly
Malone ThomasJennifer Sanderholm
Chris MayersAndrew Simmons
Brian Ashton SmithDeputy Dutton
Melina MilagrosShaniece Riley
Paul RydenRichard HeikkilaKassandra MarronAlisa SampleDenise ArribasAnna Stoddart
Daniel SalyersRyan Reinken
Wayne HughesLouis ByersJohn SchmedesThomas CurryAmber SeidelCindy Taylor
Addison TuckerDebbi SlatteryKate LeekNicki VanbelkumEls MurrayNurse Tiffany Parker
Greg ClarksonEnnis Campbell
Jackie GoldstonEmanda MahaffeyHeather RicksMarlene
Michael StuartOfficer Davis Matthews
Annie ThrashStephanie Welsh
Charlie VesciTimmy Whitehead
J. Scott BrowningBrian SanderholmBryan BergmanBlaineKirsten BensonMatt's Mom
Jeff WilliamsRoss SchellAngelica-Naia GaborLinda Perez
Stephen StarkweatherPeter Kincaid
Danny WinnBruce Tinch
Esmeree SterlingTonya Jones
Michael LawsonOfficer Jackson Charles
Connor HammondJeremy Harte
Ashlee HeathPatricia Maimoni
Jamie RenellDet. Rick Hopper
Amber NeukumCourtney Kelly
Mercedez McDowellRenee Klasky
Kristina ArjonaCousin Kelsey
Lawrence H. CollinsProsecutor James AdkinsDevin BroadbentJack the Bartender
Sydney SilverSally
Kevin ButtimerNeil RhodesMatthew FowlerDet. Rick Lincoln
Hannah Marie BaileySydney Bennett
Greg SchrefflerOfficer PaternoAdam Jack ArthurDeputy David Jones
Jennifer Christa PalmerCarolyn Slattery
Chantell D. ChristopherDispatcher Nancy Deal
Parisa JohnstonOfficer BozekDaimion JohnsonOfficer David Fairbanks
Sara GastonLynn Whitehead
Barbara Hawkins-ScottLeah FiliaggiLake RobertsMD Detective Hendley
Gabriel ManakJohnMathew MulhollandKen Dalton
Craig S. MurphyDetective FasanoRyan BurkeJamie Boyd
Jennifer PatinoManager Amanda
Roy CoulterDaniel Shurley
Kristopher CharlesOfficer Robert HansonShannon CoulterSally the Social Worker
Summer PerkinsPrison Nurse
Suzanne SalhaneyAunt AllisonMarilyn ChungFemale Student
Jack VincentyOwenGary TaylorSelf
Aquiah Ma'atHotel MaidTerrence DavisOfficer Taylor Reynolds
Melissa HaasReceptionist
Suehyla El-Attar YoungNeighbor
Joan ReillyPat LongJoseph LavenderMark WidlundJeremy WindhamDuane OwenDanielle AlagnaGabriella RodriguezKent FergusonSelfDonna MaxwellSelf (Lisa's firend)
Quinten JohnsonOfficer Jim DaleyIvory ShieldsBank Teller
Allison FarmerPamJennifer Baskette-RidingsAngelia JeffersMark KnappJakeChristopher MathisOfficer Steve LewisJulie EvansSelf (freelance writer)Kenny RodgersSelf
Rico ParisOfficer Korb
Chris MarksLt. Mark McCaslinDaniel Alfonso ContrerasCounty Sheriff DeputyDrew GilesRanger SmytheBert GrahamSelf (A.D.A. Harris County)Robert M. PoliSelf (Ret. Lieutenant Lorain PD)Darryl BookerBurt Hawthorne
Inga EissMaxineLem CollinsAuto Mechanic
Charity HitchcockGeorgianna WordenSarah NewmanSusan WilliamsCamille LandryRachel Derby
Hannah KeppleKristy Ray
Ashley BratcherLisa Brown
Tatiana ZappardinoCathy Whitehead
Jenna KanellJoi Partain
Fedor SteerGary
JoAnn WilletteDebbie Puglisi
Kathrine BarnesAmanda Parker
Grayson BerryDale
Lauren BuglioliPeggy Klinke
Jeremy T. ThomasScott Wells
Jason BurkeyOfficer Brian Lewis
Alexis LouderSabrina Davies
Autumn DialTammie Craycraft
Sylvia Grace CrimFrankie CochranJennifer FeltonNews Anchor
Britton WebbSgt. Kevin McCoy
Tiffany BlackCrime Scene Tech
Harrison StoneDaniel Ryland
Jocelyn ShelfoMarilee Manley
Julie KendallTammy Kelso
Kyle FindleyCody Simmons
Dorian LoughNarrator
Keith Arthur BoldenOfficer Scott HendleyKevin SavageDeputy Danny Frye
Jesse GallegosJon Pearson
Tony DeMilSam Grohl
Cedric GreenwayOfficer Clark
Jermaine RiversOfficer Mike Giroux
Justin James BoykinCraig Madden
Erin OwnbeyBecky Tulley
Wendy WynneDetective Sandy Farmer
Jon StaffordDr. Charles Konschnik
Zele AvradopoulosMadeline Hammack
Austin FreemanJace Howell
Sharonne LanierSheila Dates
Katerina EichenbergerChristine Kent
Scott DealJohn Mathers
Kate DaileyKimberly Cook
Jana AllenMichelle Cable
Scott Daniel JohnsonAgent Strickland
Daniel AnnoneDerek Windsor
Joshua LamboySam Frier
Pamela GoldJeanne Smith
Brooke Jaye TaylorJanet Overton
Jesse MalinowskiHooper Goodwin
Zane StephensScott Flores
Ian GreggJeremy Demann
Paul WilsonJohn Moore
Josh WarrenChester McKnight
Renae GeerlingsDet. Pattie Munley
Nicky BuggsBelinda Henry
Tywayne WheattCarl Longley
Michele YeagerSally Miller
Tyler Kay WhitleyRegina Dates
Keith BrooksTim Follet
Eugene H. Russell IVOfficer Fred Stienhorst
Kylie ContrearyTiffany Cole
Royal AllenLt. Scott McLaren
Taina DominguezMarie Mendez
Matthew RimmerSheriff Holland
Gabriella OrtizOfficer Angela Batson
Santiago CiriloDetective Sam Solivan
Brandon GibsonSteven Oliver
Jordan SalloumDavid Gerard
Adam BrudnickiMark Sparks
Javier Vazquez Jr.Carlos
Pat DortchDr. Lars SimpsonKennedy BriceBeth Stauffer
Shaun MacLeanSilas Howard
Adam MurrayLarry
Aaron Quick NelsonSpecial Agent Thigpen
Katelyn FarrugiaJen Smith
Mark CostelloJohn Roehm - Week 1
Michael HansonMatt Kelso
Kristina CohenAlexa Evans
Nene NwokoAna the Housekeeper
Roxzane T. MimsVernice Holloman
Mary Patricia SeidelPriscilla Gustafson
Andrew HunterLarry Simmons
Kelly AngellTanya Petro
Skyler McIntoshWaitress
Brian ChildersNino Puglisi
Anastasia EdwardsSarah Jones
P. David MillerDansby Sutherland
Euseph MessiahSam Hobson
Annie CookMary Lou Seymour
Alicia KelleyDonna
Derrick J. HaywoodCarl Simmons
Megan MessmerDetective TannerAlan RichmondBill Hale
Peg O'KeefDaphne Steele
Eric EsquerJerry Glaser
Kristi RayMicha Pate
Kathleen HoganDorothy Boyer
Crystal Lee BrownDoctor
Michael A. CookKevin Shenefelt
Leigh HigginbothamSandy ShultzEric CroasKen Atkins
Phil ArmijoChuck Crawford
Alan HecknerDetective Mike Landers
Ross CrainPatrick Kennedy
John HardyDet. Lyle Johnston
Briana StarksTicket Taker
Jessica FontaineOfficer McKnight
Joseph Curtis CallenderDetective Owen McDaniels
Andrés EricksonAvery
Emily LaneLinda Noll
Dietrich TeschnerKyle Jacobson
John CrowDonald Royce
David TempleDetective Frank Shelton
Barry PiacenteScott Terwilliger
Joe MorelliDetective Bob Anton
Hannah BlackGina Tenney
Erik BelloNick Sanders
Sean FreelandBobby SpargoLogan McHughMichael Massey
Marlon PerrierNelson Jones
Akil JacksonDonald Flagg
Keith HudsonJames VanDivnerChloe StaffordNatalie Purdie
Jose Miguel VasquezDetective Mike Martin
Eva PetersonMegStephen Shane MartinAgent Newson Summerlin
Anthony E. WilliamsChris Hanney
Sandra Lee-Oian ThomasLauren Spector
Joseph MazzaKevin Wells
Katie StottlemireAnnie Andrews
Robert HatchRichard Overton
Derek McDonnellJames Lewis
Tony BottorffJohn Romberg
Kamille McCuinCherry Lee Jones
Haley GoldmanKaren Widdoss
Cecil LoveAlbert Lopez
Patrick FlanaganOfficer Robert Walls
Bob LanoueRussell Sedelmeir
Ruan MartinsBob CarterMorgan BurchJessie Andrews
Diesel MadkinsOfficer Adam JordanJonathan HorneSteven Miller
Ariadne JosephFenita Mayberry
Mary McGahrenDenise Sam Cali
Dominick RacanoTed Winters
Karen Kaia LiversDetective Reba Lambert
Jerry GriffinOfficer Bartlett
Mari KasuyaStudent #7
Todd SheelerDetective Gerald Swayze
Dexter TillisKeith HenryLauren BoydLaura April
Kaycie LeeJessica Cable
Ryan KingAllan Sinclair
Jonathan D. WilliamsRev. Irv StaufferJay CroftCarl Franklin
Rishik PatelMiles Garrett
Tony J. ScottJoe the Bartender
Michael Lee KimelMing Shiue
Samuel GoergenLogan
Barbara BenevilleShirley BrogleyMimi GouldAlma List
Sam Wages JohnsonPolice Officer
Cindy CopelandLaverne Whitehead
Caleb J. SpivakHarvey Robinson
Matt McVayRonald Wilson
Marty StonerockLaurie Cabot
Travis YoungClay Starbuck
Meghan PerryAudrey Mabrey
Skyler AdamsJimmy Mickel
Lisha WheelerCiara
Amy HuiDr. Agnes Miyani
Brad BrinkleyRon Gibson
Aaron WigginsUniformed Officer #1
Mike SeniorDale Scheanette
Joseph YatesMike Partain
David Rucker IIINorman PrescottCody GriffisOfficer Henry Collins
Deborah JaneStacy Adams
Emily SoppeJessyca Mullenberg
Kerri J. BaldwinGloria the Manager
Christen ShariceTheona HopkinsBrianna Quinn LewisDonna Anderson
John Jackson HunterJosh Cable
Ciarra SillerMarie Wood
Roberta SetzuVeronica
Allen O'ReillyHarbor MasterVictoria AnastasiJennifer Hitchcock
Christie McNabHeather Kelso
Mary Katherine O'DonnellPatty ListRandall CoreOfficer Kelly
Hope JordanCarrie CauldillThomas AikenCreepy College Guy #3
Vanessa AraneguiCrystal Frier
Stephanie WyattSusan OliverElle WhitfieldRosie Paoletto
Anthony PaderewskiJames Ponder
Phoenix WashingtonOfficer Stephen Holder
Angel LuisJacob Pruitt
Langley CornwellConnie Craycraft
Shannon MayersRebecca Purdie
Kristen WhartonMonica Lukasavige
Bryan Terry SnellSteve Timmons
Travis WestRon
Ryan BaughmanDavid Glaser
Clint WintersDetective Shaun Squyres
Timothy ScottTom McKelvey
Nicole LambBriana Helwick
Rory Callahan-FitzgeraldJason Lorendez
Jenny JenningsTracy RomoShaun JonesDeputy Marv Olson
Jason Lee BoysonFrank WoodJimmy ManfredyInvestigator Chuck BenningBen PeckMr. Lucian Tenney
Greg WeeksOfficer Brian Cunningham
Jeff HuthHudson RileyHeather BloomNancy LudwigSusie WallKatybeth Wooldridge
Fidelus SingletonClarence Purdie
Nir GuzinskiBar Patron
Jeffrey Charles MorganJohn ListChas HarveyNick Barnes
Brittany Horn
Lucas HicksJohn Peters
Myron Parker WrightMarcus
Denice RiveraDr. Leah BentonRyan RoetsTrent SimmonsTom FarrellJeffrey MaxwellJohn 'Fletch' FletcherDennis Connor
Rae BeckaElaine Moore
Todd BrownTommy RayEmily ShaulesDorothy GlaserSamantha BrightJenna
Adam LabordeArt LudwigStephanie OlneyPat WisnoskyTrevor GarnerYoung Kenny Linscott
Henry Frost IIIOfficer BraxtonRon BushLloyd JenkinsAly Ward AzevedoAnna WoodBrad ThomasonEdward Burke
Megan RosenChristy Williams
Jennifer ReneeAnna FoxCollin Alexander BrownDetective Gary Killam
Erin UnderwoodNurse Tina RussellSeth KempLeonard Tilton
Isabella AlbertiCharlotte Schmoyer
Juanita P. TaylorShawn Morales
Joy UwinezaTiffany Barrett
Chris KontopidisDrea
Madison ReitzNicole Mason
Sandy GivelberBar PatronOlaolu WinfunkeJerry
Neala CohenHazel Moore
Rultz RaymondDetective Swayze Partner
Jonathan Lee TaylorBobby Evans
Mary MeyerJennifer Partain
David Christian WelbornMike Iseman
Rob SpringerAndyBryan BrendleDetective Tommy Lenoir
Shaun MixonLucas
Tommy LeNoirSelf
Aleq BeyDeputy Jim DudleyElizabeth YoumanDeserie Washington
MaryJean FetonElizabeth RoehmJabari MarshallDeputy Mike Reilly
Lynne SmithPhyllisDonnie EvansDetective Jason WebberVictoria EalyAnita Wooldridge
Nicholas TecoskySteve Rine
Nicholas CordtsHunter MonroeDiane BrayCarol SumnerKristy WhiteBetty Widdos
Kat KilkennySueJoe NarsavageDoctor
Patti A MactasDorothy SandersShawn RobertsOfficer Hoffman
Christopher BullockKevinAlicia CoxJulie
Michaela CronanDeputy JenkinsCandace MabryDetective Lorna Jenkins
Rocco PoveromoCaptain Leo RyanBrook ToddBillyJoe SykesDet. Paul Sigsworth
Mark CampbellWalter Dornan
Lory CoxRosalyn Kaplan
Joshua HowlandMark HaskinsNick HeeterTimmy
Chris FernandesMarcusGord JamesDr. WalkerJames ColeRobert HansonJessica YoungLisa Paterno
David PlunkettFloydNnaemeka OkekeDeputy Bruce JohnsonChristopher Van MeterJohn Cali
Sloan StewartSara WhiteCory Michael PeelerRyan OliverGeoffrey CulbertsonBillFord SmithJosh Gordon
Katherine OlsonJenae
Jack AndrewsChristopher BurnsReid MeadowsMarshall Starbuck
Darian FisherPolice Officer
Michael T. DeanJeffrey Gorton
Michael P. WalkerOfficer Ed Doyle
JoAnna LoreneRestaurant Patron #4Rita RuckerSchool Board MemberBrent BrooksRonald Stapp
Spencer MumfordBilly CableCindy SherwoodAlice Hall
Eric LeeDr. David ClaroniDaniel JamesBennie FrierDevin Marcus MillerDonald Glen Everett
Eli T. PeñaChip HojanAllen ParkerTrooper James MonkelisShannon ThomasTow Truck DriverCorey SnowdenDeputy Paul ClemmonsDaniel OrellanaHarold the PostmanStacy MelichJudy LinscottLoretta Reviere-PerryHospital Patient #1Paul PetrusDeputy Elwood McKinney
Becca PotterSandy
Eric Weston DavisToddWhit DaviesCaptain Finn
Amy ToddMary RayAdam ColeBruce NixonVaughn WoodFarmerMark KincaidDennis RineChandler LaneBrent Baxter
Amy MeridithUniformed Officer #2
Faye NovickLois PearsonGreg CrewsKenneth BoonstraArt LudwigSelf - Nancy's Husband
Reuven AviDetective RowanEric LavoieChief Roland VaughnLarry BlanksPedestrianDenise Sam-CaliSelf - Victim
Kayal KhannaDan
Marlon BurnleyKevin BullockJesse KingNick HansonAmanda MaddoxNell
Amanda DeljouDarleneGene ReillyDeputy Craig
Alexandra BurgessPolice Officer #2Pablo IglesiasLt. Robert PoliShane HowellMichael PuglisiMadeline AcquavivaCharlotteJohnathan BlakeJimmy Easton
Reginald HeinishOfficer Steve ShumateRachel UllmanKathyVera VarlamovTracy Jones
Jamall Rashaud McMillanOfficer John Carini
Tevon PlunkettBennie Adams
George VricosDet. Justin Kaye
Pete PenuelJerry Southworth
John RymerLt. Bill SassAva MetalloGabby NunnPaul McComiskeyReggie SumnerIan Patrick MendesPatrick FlaniganH. Patrik CoyneFreddie MooreRodrick GoinsHarry the Room Attendant
Jennica HillRachel HughesAndrew j SpinksDonald SchultzJules HavenGirlfriend #1Nargis AnistonEMT
Nicole Paris WilliamsBarbara NunnTim HabegerGene Clark
Sondra DarlingtonSara Johnson
Jordan IacovellaDanny LaPlante
Justin T. HooperFrank
Bryson TrumanJohnMarvel BellMary GraceMarcus DurhamMartinJohn AndrewDetective Timothy EvansGrace ThomasMaria MoyersDon ScullySheriff MontgomeryDebbie RiddleSelf - Peggy's Sister
Carmella NucciMarissa HillDebra Puglisi-SharpSelf - Widow of Anthony 'Nino' Puglisi)Brandon MitchellPhil ArciaRory LedbetterLt. Todd Halford
Robert ParishLarry Seymour
James SwendsenSGT. SullivanJake DeLaughterFred ListWyman TannehillDetective Mike LarsenLee BuecheleCaretaker
Frank McAdamsSelf - Author, Final AffairKathy WinchellSusan VanDivnerDarius RedmonSheriff Officer #2Cira ThigpenAbigail GustafsonSimon KeyEugene SlatteryMatthew FowlerDetective Rick LincolnCharles PittardGreg SandersonBrakki BrazzleDetective Walter JensenMalachi SeniorAgent GlennSherrie PennOfficer Julia VasquezArthur YorkDep. Brian MitchellReggie HarperDetective Bob CosaChristopher MalcolmDon WatkinsR. Barry GreenJorge Fernandez
J Michael GreyMark Waters
Shon MiddlebrooksPrecious BrightVickyShane William ShifflettSheriff Officer #4Ken DohsePastor David BurkhartDior ChoiThang KhuuBethany TillerCoronerJamie SatterfieldSelf - Journalist Knoxville News SentinelKenny GuerraJustin Helwick
Sean NateghiAlex ParksBarin NelyseTrooper Heather HolveyAdrian MechelleSandy PrescottDerek Ryan DukeUniformed Officer #2Steven L. Thornton Jr.Marshall Steven Shipley
Chris MasonDeputy JarvisHerrari HamiltonSamantha
Abigail Susan WilliamsBecky Hill
Robert D WattsGeorge (Bartender)Rob HaysAgent Eugene WilliamsBecka HardySaraDavin DeLoatchDetective Crews
Samuel Aaron SimmonsDetective Dan SnyderPaulette CainSusan MoorePaul NicelySgt. John VolgerRalph RuizSgt. Pat ChavezAmy StormantGardening NeighborGraham HuntMichael Jackson
Lauren Emily TownsendFelicia CostelloSandra BowmanNancy Waters
Tom HendersonSelf - JournalistToynal DavisNurse FrancisPat YoungDeputy Jacobs
Kayleigh StoverSutton StarbuckKatie KyleTracy Jackson
Ash HamiltonZoeBrayden HuffmasterDaniel BoydRachael LeviSarahLynn GraceKelly MartinAlex Pierce LingOfficer Aaron JonesPatience BranhamSelf - Former Prosecutor, Shelby CountyJim CotsakisRonald GreshamRhett JohnsonGeneElizabeth WalkerSelf - ProsecutorDouglas GoodoienDavid KlineRidley MeadowsLoghan StarbuckDennis B. IsraelGreg Moore
Karlton DavisAddy MeyerBrian FeysJudge SheehanKathryn MeksavanhKate DuPrisMike LarsenSelf - DetectiveTimothy CarneySelf - Lt., Orange County CA Sheriff's Department (ret.)Jordan SollieGus the BartenderDustin DodsonBen HoganMatt BellBrian PhilliipsM. Kinney LeeThomas Pate Sr.Steve HondrosOfficer Andrew ScottCindy SanderholmSelf - Jodi's MotherTerri RineSelf - Micah's MotherCasey RineSelf - Micah's BrotherDennis RineSelf - Micah's FatherBraeden OrrDeputy Silas GreeneJefferson BellThomas PateDonna ChalmersHelen ListDylan AbaletaRestaurant Patron #1Brandon Ralph WoodBenJames FondoSelf - Capt., Broward County FL Sheriff's Office (ret)Jordan DemersDanaMark McCaslinSelf - DetectiveNatalie Ruth DavisHolly SimmonsBen SilverKevin MillerRandy SchultzSelf - Former Reporter
Penny Pandis MooreSharon ClevengerPatrick M. BishopGrady MasonRick LincolnSelf - Delray Beach Police Department
Jeffrey James HigginsJeffrey HigginsDonnie NorrellSelf - Investigator, Norfolk VA Police DepartmentDarlene SillitoeSelf - Debra's SisterTravis Ryan BurdetteJake LukasavigeLori Legleiter-VirdenSelf - Jodi's FriendMargaret PressSelf - Author, A Scream on the WaterBruce HendersonJohn Roehm-week 2Ella Marie CyrPam SummersHolyn ThigpenTailgater #9
Rolando MadrigalGerry deJesusDavid FallettiSelf - DetectiveConrad ProsniewskiSelf - Lt., Salem P.D.
Margaret W BrownDebbie Klinke Riddle
Pam SmithSusanSteve FlaniganJon MillerJaxon PetruskiGabe NunnTiara ArvingerRachelJeremiah SmithJohn List Jr.John LawsSheriff Officer #6Leshay LoweryJennaDarrel ErvinRev. Ivon HarrisPeter BolebruchJanet's SonGinnie Lee HouseTara ClarkJames HamiltonLarry TaylorJt CorbittJames MonkelisSelf - Trooper, Pennsylvania State Police (ret.)
Darryl Harrison Ford IIDetective Kevin HarrisEileen Walsh-PhippsSelf - Martha's FriendTara WoodleeSelf - Ashleigh's MotherWesley HuffmanOfficer Daryl HamiltonTom TaaffeFrank SandersAlan Patrick HarperJose AlvarezToby PrattDale JohnstonScott McLarenSelf - Fmr. Chief, New Castle DE Police DepartmentDeserie WhiteheadSelf - Natalie's SisterShirley BrogleySelf - Debra's Co-Worker
Stephan LucianoBrian SmithMarie WoodSelf - Jeanne's DaughterDouglas SepicSelf - Prosecutor, Fayette County PennsylvaniaKeith BlountChoir MemberMitzi McLeodOfficer Megan LeonardCamille AnnanAnnette Cooper JohnstonCasie BryantMaggie (Neighbor)Calli AldenNoelle JohnstonPaul SzychSelf - CMDR., New Mexico Domestic Violence Stalking UnitTodd HalfordSelf - Lt., Bartlett Police Dept.Julia MartinEmily NewmanBill JenningsSelf - Patrol Man, Salem P.D.Mark WynnSelf - Lt., United States Dept. of Justice - Stalking ConsultantShawn RobertsOfficer Sam JonesSamia KhanDaphne AndrewsJustin HooperCarlJessica CableSelf - Michelle's DaughterNatalie PurdieSelf - Former DancerChris WhiteJamesDavid HubbardGeorge BabbScott TerwilligerSelf - Sgt., Roanoke VA Police DepartmentDavid JonesSelf - Dep., Marshall County OK Sheriff's OfficeHeather LaraSelf - Ashleigh's FriendHannah ZeldinJennifer GlaserSarah NewmanSusan WilliamsMadeline HammackSelf - Jeanne's FriendAnna WoodSelf - Jeanne's DaughterMarie VillarbaSelf - Peggy's Friend and Former TeacherChristine KentSelf - Former ModelOwen WrightMichael CaudillDan WeikelSelf - Staff Writer, Los Angeles TimesLinda KronerSelf - Janet's Friend & ColleagueAshley T. JohnChima BensonJoshua KovalscikDavid KrarupJim SchwalbeLouis BarneyJessica KolodzyJustin CaroJohnny FranceSelf - Sheriff, Madison County Montana (ret.)Jeff KarcherJami GoldsteinSelf - Alan's DaughterKim HudsonSelf - Commnication Supervisor (ret.)Kevin KelleherSelf - Owner, Big Sky NewspaperJay CosgroveSelf - Resident Dep., Madison Country MT Sheriff's Office (ret.)Cheryl Burton Nelson
Barry PeavyGun Show Attendee (uncredited)Karl FunkAshleigh's Stepfather (uncredited)Bret E. BensonProbation Officer Eric Taylor (uncredited)China Lee SimsPolice Officer (uncredited)Daniel ScatesSandy's Friend (uncredited)Cameron SweetPolice Officer (uncredited)Marilea ButlerSearcher (uncredited)